Review: ‘A Killer Night in Studio City’ Serves Up Murder, Mystery, and Italian Victuals at Vitello’s

Date:

At Vitello’s Restaurant in Studio City, Hollywood history is already part of the atmosphere. Autographed photographs of famous patrons line the walls, recalling decades of visits by actors, musicians, and entertainment personalities. It is a fitting backdrop for A Killer Night in Studio City, an immersive murder mystery that transforms the celebrated Italian restaurant into the setting for an imagined Hollywood scandal, replete with suspicious characters, live music, a delicious dinner, and plenty of opportunities for audience participation.

Anthony Carro and Brianna Kellum in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell

Written and produced by Kevin Allen Jackson and Kristine Dickson, directed by Noah Blake, and presented by DETNY Theatrical Productions, the production transports audiences to 1958, when the entertainment industry was populated by larger-than-life personalities whose carefully cultivated public images often concealed more complicated private lives.

The occasion is a memorial for Sophia Vance, a beloved and beautiful young movie star whose promising career has ended abruptly following a mysterious automobile accident along Pacific Coast Highway in Malibu. Like Marilyn Monroe or James Dean, Sophia seems destined to become another Hollywood legend whose untimely death only intensifies public fascination.

Even before the performance begins, guests receive a program and newspaper containing a fictional account by Hollywood gossip columnist Edith Sinclair. The report raises troubling questions about Sophia’s death. Why was a pack of cigarettes discovered near the body when the actress supposedly never smoked? Why was her identifying beauty mark missing? And why is there no record of a driver’s license issued under Sophia Vance’s name in city records?

These details provide an intriguing introduction to the mystery, inviting guests to begin forming theories before encountering the suspects themselves.

Noah Blake and Brittany Pirozzoli in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell

The action starts on the sidewalk outside Vitello’s, along Tujunga Avenue, where Edith Sinclair, portrayed by Sarah Cornell after taking over the role from Sarah Wolter for the remaining performances, addresses the gathering through a vintage-style microphone. Cornell enthusiastically embraces the character’s breathless pursuit of a sensational scoop, turning each juicy detail into a potentially career-defining revelation. Her heightened delivery and expressive reactions generate early laughs while establishing Edith as a persistent figure throughout the evening.

Soon, Mama Monica Vitello (Brianna Kellum) welcomes the mourners inside. The passionate Italian matriarch has personal reasons to be distressed, particularly given Sophia’s relationship with her son, Gianni Vitello, a Hollywood leading man better known by his screen name, Johnny Turner (Anthony Carro).

Monica believes Johnny was engaged to Sophia, pointing to a family ring as evidence. Johnny disputes that understanding, and the disagreement becomes one of several uncertainties surrounding the deceased starlet. When a coveted statuette disappears and a ghostly apparition makes an appearance in a downstairs room, the memorial begins to resemble something considerably more sinister.

Kellum is especially enjoyable as Monica, committing wholeheartedly to the character’s accent, maternal protectiveness, and emotional volatility. Her interactions with guests help dissolve the customary separation between performers and spectators, while her spirited portrayal lends the proceedings an appealing sense of spontaneity.

Brittany Pirozzoli and Brianna Kellum in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell

The action eventually moves upstairs, where guests settle into assigned seats in Vitello’s inviting dining space. Chandeliers, richly colored furnishings, and the intimate layout complement the production’s old-Hollywood aesthetic. Rather than functioning as a conventional theatrical venue, Vitello’s becomes an active part of the Golden Age world.

Dinner is another substantial pleasure, marked by a generous Italian buffet with meatballs, pasta, chicken Parmesan, garlic toast, salad, and cannoli. The delectable meatballs and delicately prepared pasta are particularly satisfying, while the crisp, fresh cannoli provides an excellent finish. The food feels integral to the evening rather than an incidental accompaniment to the proceedings.

Meanwhile, the investigation continues through exchanges between the characters, interactions with diners, and additional clues placed in boxes at the tables. Guests can examine documents and background information, compare hypotheses, and become increasingly involved in determining what happened to Sophia.

Anthony Carro, Brittany Pirozzoli, and Noah Blake in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell

Blake, who also portrays Ronnie Bennett, brings considerable charm to the 90-minute show. Ronnie is a struggling actor with ambitions involving a television detective and a ghostly canine companion, though his own connections to Sophia complicate his position in the investigation. Blake plays him with an easygoing humor and natural rapport with fellow performers, frequently finding opportunities for playful remarks that make the experience feel responsive.

That relaxed, improvisational quality extends throughout the ensemble. The performers appear genuinely comfortable together, allowing exchanges to develop organically without losing sight of the underlying story.

Carro gives Johnny a comparatively restrained, earnest quality. His bewilderment at the accusations and revelations surrounding Sophia feels credible, even as the character’s conflicting accounts and questionable decisions leave room for misgivings. Carro’s ability to suggest both genuine affection and possible concealment makes Johnny a fascinating figure.

Brittany Pirozzoli and Brianna Kellum in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell

Scott Striegel supplies a more flamboyant presence as Clarkston, the makeup artist who helped construct Sophia’s celebrated screen image. His wounded pride, professional frustrations, and evident desire for recognition suggest someone whose relationship with Hollywood success has become deeply personal. Striegel makes Clarkston’s vanity fun to watch while preserving the resentment beneath it.

Brittany Pirozzoli, meanwhile, brings the requisite glamour and self-possession to Sophia. Her assured bearing and period-appropriate manner evoke the image of a star who understands the influence of her own celebrity. As her character becomes a more immediate part of the action, Pirozzoli gives the unfolding mystery additional momentum.

Cornell remains equally committed as Edith, whose determination to expose the ultimate Hollywood bombshell occasionally borders on obsession. Her rapid-fire observations, exaggerated discoveries (including her repeated declaration that she’s uncovered “the story of the century!”), and amusingly awkward exchanges with Johnny provide some of the occasion’s lighter moments.

Scott Striegel and Sarah Wolter in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell

Music gives the production another distinctive dimension. Accompanied by pianist Jonny Perl, whose understated playing supports the performers without overwhelming them, the cast delivers a selection of familiar popular songs. Numbers including “My Way,” “Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered,” “Call Me Irresponsible,” and “You Don’t Own Me” add a supper-club sensibility and offer opportunities for the characters to reveal different sides of themselves.

The technical elements further reinforce the setting. Matt Richter’s lighting helps frame the action within an inviting dining environment, allowing guests to follow the unfolding drama without diminishing the natural ambiance. Juliette Lunger’s costumes, assisted by Ciara Cruz, capture the elegance and theatricality of the epoch, while Jake Eberle’s sound design punctuates important revelations. Video production by Charlie Chappell is another welcome touch, particularly a cleverly filmed trailer featuring Pirozzoli and Carro as Sophia and Johnny in their picture, On the Road to Hana, which is projected for the audience.

There are moments when the production could benefit from a stronger buildup of comic or dramatic tension. Individual jokes, eyebrow-raising developments, and surprises are enjoyable, but neither the laughter nor the suspense consistently reaches the kind of crescendo that might make this whodunnit even more memorable. Still, this is a relatively modest reservation about an experience whose pleasures extend well beyond unearthing the truth.

Indeed, the production’s origins make its choice of venue especially suitable. Jackson and Dickson conceived the idea after visiting Vitello’s for Blake’s birthday, eventually developing a concept that draws upon the restaurant’s distinctive place in Tinseltown culture.

Sarah Wolter, Brianna Kellum, Anthony Carro, and Brittany Pirozzoli in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell

By the conclusion, guests have an opportunity to identify the culprit, with a dessert voucher for a future visit rewarding those who solve the puzzle.

What ultimately makes A Killer Night in Studio City so appealing is the way its many components work together. The performances are inspired, the audience involvement is genuinely engaging, the music adds welcome variety, and the Italian dinner is thoroughly satisfying. Above all, Vitello’s lends the production an authenticity that would be difficult to reproduce in a traditional theater.

For anyone seeking an unconventional evening that combines Hollywood nostalgia, theatrical flourishes, and a sumptuous meal, this is a murder mystery well worth investigating.

Cover image caption: Scott Striegel and Brittany Pirozzoli in DETNY Theatrical Productions’ A Killer Night in Studio City at Vitello’s. Photo by Charlie Chappell.

A Killer Night in Studio City continues at Vitello’s, 4349 Tujunga Avenue in Studio City, with performances Thursday, October 8th at 6 p.m.; Saturday, October 17th at 2 p.m.; Sunday, October 18th at 2 p.m.; Tuesday, October 20th at 6 p.m.; Wednesday, October 21st at 6 p.m.; Thursday, October 29th at 6 p.m.; and Saturday, October 31st at 5 p.m. and 8 p.m. Tickets include dinner and the theatrical experience. Tickets and additional information are available at akillernightlive.com. 

Imaan Jalali
Imaan Jalali
Imaan has been the Arts & Culture Editor of LAexcites since the digital magazine went live in 2015.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here
Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

‘A Christmas Carol’ Gives Scrooge His 46th Holiday Wake-Up Call at South Coast Repertory

Christmas cookies vanish from the plate, festive decorations reclaim...

Review: ‘Romeo and Juliet: Time Enough for Love’ Reverses the Ages and Deepens the Heartache

Star-crossed lovers can exist in any age bracket, which...

Patti LuPone and Scott Bakula Bring Two Worlds to LA Opera’s ‘Candide’

LA Opera may just have saved its best for...

Review: ‘Oh, Mary!’ Hilariously Turns the White House Upside Down at the Ahmanson

In Cole Escola's gloriously distorted version of American history,...