Harold Hill has no trouble convincing a town it needs a marching band. Teaching one is another matter. That gap between confidence and competence fuels Meredith Willson’s The Music Man, the enduring musical comedy returning to Los Angeles for a limited engagement at the Ahmanson Theatre, October 27–November 8.
Set in 1912, the story follows a traveling salesman who arrives in River City, Iowa, and persuades families to purchase instruments and uniforms for a boys’ band he has no intention of training. Among the few residents who question him is Marian Paroo, the town’s librarian and piano teacher. Their unexpected attraction threatens his escape, while Willson’s songs range from the exuberance of “Seventy-Six Trombones” and “Trouble” to the tenderness of “Till There Was You.”
With book, music, and lyrics by Willson and a story credited to Willson and Franklin Lacey, The Music Man opened on Broadway in 1957. It won the Tony Award for Best Musical and ran for 1,375 performances, securing a place among the American musical’s Golden Age favorites. Its portrait of small-town life has retained an appeal that is partly nostalgic and partly rooted in its playful portrayal of human gullibility.

Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster brought renewed Broadway attention to the musical in 2022. Southern California audiences also saw Tony nominee Adam Pascal play Hill in 5-Star Theatricals’ 2019 production in Thousand Oaks. This latest engagement brings Big League Productions’ non-equity national tour to the Ahmanson, with Matt Lenz directing and Joshua Bergasse choreographing. The staging has its own sets and projections while retaining Santo Loquasto’s costumes from that Broadway revival.
Elliott Andrews plays Hill opposite Elizabeth D’Aiuto as Marian, with Savannah Stevenson as Mrs. Paroo, Paul Urriola as Marcellus Washburn, and Patrick Blashill as Mayor Shinn. A Boston Conservatory graduate whose stage credits include The Secret Garden and Camelot, D’Aiuto makes her national tour debut in the role.
LAexcites recently spoke with D’Aiuto about making Marian her own, the demands of touring, and why The Music Man continues to resonate with audiences.

Marian is often defined by her skepticism toward Harold Hill, but there’s considerably more to her character. What aspects of her personality do you find most compelling, and where do you see yourself in her?
D’Aiuto: She is skeptical of him, but only because of how closed off she is as a person. She helps support her family, she owns a business, she works at the library and teaches kids music. That’s her agenda. When this guy comes along, it throws her off balance, and she knows what he’s doing is a complete scam. She says she’s going to look in the reference books for information about him and discovers what he’s doing.
But what’s cool is that she lets this all play out because she sees what he’s doing to this town. People who were enemies are now dancing in the street. The most important thing for Marian is that her little brother, who has a lisp, is now excited about playing in a band.
She also sees what he’s bringing out in her. He brings out this vulnerability, goofiness and comedic side of her, things that were already there but really come out when she finds someone who matches her directly. They challenge each other, but not in a mean or unfriendly way.
And by the end of the show, she’s grateful for the opportunity he’s given her to love and, ultimately, to stop and smell the roses.

How would you characterize the evolving relationship between Marian and Harold, and what have you discovered about their dynamic through working with Elliott Andrews?
D’Aiuto: If you have an interview with him, he’ll say there’s so much happening between the two. There’s trust and chemistry. As we’ve gotten to know each other on a friendly level, working and traveling together, we’ve built up a nice bond that comes across onstage.
It’s a great time working with him. I trust him, he’s a wonderful scene partner, and there’s no one better you could ask for. It’s fun to play onstage as you kind of go from this enemies-to-lovers thing, and I have the best time because of that trust. We also care about each other as human beings, often asking each other how we’re doing.
People don’t realize how much of us is in these characters. He does stuff that might make me break, but it works because they’re flirting.
If I get pissed at him one day (laughs), it might even work within the dynamic of the characters, but we’re always working as a team.

After months of performing Marian, has your understanding of her changed in unexpected ways? How much freedom do you have to explore subtle variations in your performance from night to night?
D’Aiuto: I think what was really cool was working with Matt Lenz, our director. We wanted to make sure this Marian wasn’t problematic in 2026. She can be characterized as falling in love with a guy who did bad things, and that’s not what we’re trying to do. We’re trying to say she’s independent, a business owner, and she knows what’s going on, but it’s okay.
Yes, it’s a love story, but what we’re also communicating is that she’s grateful for what he’s given her. He’s opened her eyes to the possibility of finding love, even if she’s willing to let him go. That’s what we’re trying to do with this Marian.
But of course, it’s me, and I’m sensitive, vulnerable, funny and goofy at times. And most of my feedback about Marian is that she’s relatable, and I appreciate that because I’m trying to make her relatable to the generation of people watching the show.
I’m paying homage to the classic performers who’ve played her, like Barbara Cook, Shirley Jones and Sutton Foster, but I’m also bringing a little bit of me, which is fun and exciting. And I’m glad Matt Lenz has given me permission to do that.
Every night, it’s different. There are some audiences who get it, and others are more demure in their reactions. One night, I was singing “My White Knight”—it’s her ‘want’ song, where she’s saying she just wants someone who will talk and listen to her.
And there’s a moment when I say I want him to be “more interested in me than he is in himself,” and one audience member shouted, ‘You go, girl!’ The audience laughed and cheered, and it was one of the best moments because it showed that the audience was listening.

What’s proven most demanding about sustaining a leading role night after night, and have you developed a routine that helps meet that challenge?
D’Aiuto: Marian Paroo is a dream-come-true role for me, and I’ve always wanted to lead a national tour. I’ve worked as a swing before, covering eight tracks, but it’s a dream to lead a show.
It’s demanding, and I have to take care of myself. On the road, you’re on the bus for eight hours, and then you’re doing a show. It can be taxing on your voice and mental health. I just try to get enough sleep, drink enough water, go to the gym, lift weights, eat well, and then I do a 15- to 20-minute vocal workout beforehand, steam, nebulize, all of that (laughs).
Thankfully, my training has prepared me for this moment. I went to the Boston Conservatory. I’ve had a lot of amazing coaches who have prepared me vocally and given me the stamina to do this eight times a week.

The 2022 Broadway revival starring Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster brought renewed global attention to The Music Man. What influence, if any, do you think that production has had on audience expectations for subsequent interpretations, including your own? Did you see it?
D’Aiuto: I wish I did! Elliott Andrews saw it, and he’ll say they were two stars, and both very shiny.
Our version is not influenced by that production beyond what we’re wearing. The costumes are from that production, but ours is a whole new production. And what’s perfect is that we’re a jewel box of a musical, bringing back the Golden Age.
There are modern elements with video projections and sliding panels, and we have a gorgeous set that I can’t believe we travel with everywhere. Josh Bergasse’s choreography is incredible. He has those dancers kicking, and it’s a huge spectacle.
And of course, a big shout-out to our crew. We couldn’t do it without them, truly.
Behind all the spectacle of the musical, what’s special about ours is the heart underneath. We’re trying to tell this story about community, people coming together. It’s this little valentine of a show.
Meredith Willson didn’t want to make these characters fake. It’s paying homage to his hometown. There are kooky characters, but they’re all real, and that’s the point. Harold Hill comes into town and brings all these interesting characters together into one big community.

Of all the scenes and musical numbers you’re part of, which do you most look forward to performing each night, and what makes that moment particularly special to you?
D’Aiuto: Some of my favorite moments in the show are with Harold Hill, when we’re looking at each other, trying to say things, and there’s subtext. It’s true storytelling.
There’s a scene in Act II where I’m trying to process some information and figure things out while talking with him. When we’re there and the audience gets it, that’s true theater magic.
And I think of the footbridge scene, when Marian completes her journey from being skeptical to learning the truth and seeing what he does. She sings this glorious love song and tells him she knew all along. It’s so cool to go on her journey with her every night.
It is pretty profound, and I don’t think a lot of women want to settle. They’re looking for something special, and Marian finds something special.

A recent federal assessment found that 28% of American adults ages 16-65 have relatively low literacy proficiency. As River City’s librarian, what do you imagine Marian would make of that finding, and how might she respond?
D’Aiuto: If she knew this information, she’d make all the kids get into the library, read a book, read the classics, read a play, do anything they could to make sure these kids are reading, learning and using their imaginations (laughs).
We don’t need to worry about River City because all the kids here are even learning instruments, even if they can’t play (laughs).

Was there anything you were hoping I’d ask that we haven’t covered?
D’Aiuto: I think a lot of people ask, ‘Why now? Why has it stood the test of time?’ Because this musical was written in the 1950s, and it’s stood the test of time because of how iconic it is.
Meredith Willson wrote a beautiful score. It’s so nostalgic to an older generation, and this musical is being done in high schools and community theaters. It really is pure Americana and Golden Age musical theater. We love the Beetlejuices and Legally Blondes, but they wouldn’t be here without The Music Man.
To share a quick story, I was in Pensacola, Florida, and there was this man who asked after the show, ‘Who plays Marian?’ I said, ‘It’s me.’ He thought I was blonde, and I told him I wear a wig.
He said his wife, who had died a few months earlier, used to sing “Till There Was You” all the time, and he said seeing me in this production warmed his heart.
That was really bittersweet, knowing that we’re warming some hearts in the audience and bringing that nostalgia. In the world we’re in right now, we can use fun, live theater, nostalgia and a great story about bringing a community together.
Cover image caption: Elizabeth D’Aiuto and Elliott Andrews in the 2026 National Tour of Meredith Willson’s The Music Man. Photo by Marshall Meadows.
Center Theatre Group presents Meredith Willson’s The Music Man from Tuesday, October 27th through Sunday, November 8th, at the Ahmanson Theatre in downtown Los Angeles. For tickets, performance schedules, and additional information, visit centertheatregroup.org.